[网址导航] 登录 

印度比中国强大吗,印网友:中国GDP远超印度GDP

来源:  BBSGood社区    时间:2019-04-20 11:00:11   关注:157   转发


Is India stronger than China?(3)


印度比中国强大吗?(3)


Quora读者的评论:


Shreekanth Prabhu


Originally Answered: Who is stronger, India or China?


Economically if you go by the size of GDP, China has 4 times that of India (at least). But per-capita income-wise China is not in the league of developed nations. China also has lot of poor people. . Again Militarily China is stronger and it has made greater progress in manufacturing itself. India has many Corporations which can be global companies on their own. China essentially has been a value-adder. India has greater head-room to show its mettle in research as well. India needs to play to its strength. If India can get rid of its legacy systems and mind-set India can lead.


最初的问题是:谁更强大,印度还是中国?


从经济上看,如果按GDP规模计算,中国GDP至少是印度GDP的4倍。但就人均收入而言,中国并不在发达国家之列。中国也有很多穷人。中国军事更加强大,在制造业方面也取得了更大的进步。印度有很多可以独立成为全球性公司的公司。印度有更大的空间来展示它在研究方面的实力。印度需要发挥自己的优势。如果印度能摆脱其历史遗留问题和思维定势,印度就能领先。


 


Vdhay Kumar N, Consultant at Oil and Gas Industry (2017-present)


Is India stronger than China?


thanks for A2A


Strength is just a perspective, England is so small and with limited population and monarchy but you can remember how it played a big role in colonization and world history.


Russia and USA, they too with minimum population are so much forward and protect their very long borders with available manpower.


Hope India will go ahead with more of works and not words.


印度比中国强大吗?


谢谢你提问这个问题。


实力只是一个视角,英国弹丸之地,人口有限,还是君主政体,但你还记得它曾在殖民和世界历史上扮演过非常重要的角色吧。


俄罗斯和美国,他们也是人口很少的国家,可他们远远超过我们,能用可动用的人力保护他们很长的边界。


希望印度继续干实事,不要假大空。


 


Akshay Rathore, IFS(PROBATION) at MP Forest Department (2018-present)


Originally Answered: China or India, who is stronger?


Economically china's GDP is far more than india's. Social and health indicators viz infant mortality rate , maternal mortality rates , life expectancy, human development index value , proportion of poor's etc. Politically China is permanent member of UN security council so he has special veto power which India has not. Strategically and militarily China has upper hand in both conventional and unconventional warheads. So right now India is not at par with China. But we can because of our favourable demography and resources.


最初的问题是:中国和印度,谁更强大?


经济上,中国的GDP远远超过印度。社会急卫生指标包括婴儿死亡率、孕产妇死亡率、预期寿命、人类发展指数、贫困人口比例等。政治上,中国是联合国安理会常任理事国,所以他拥有印度没有的特别否决权。在战略和军事上,中国在常规和非常规弹头上都处于优势。所以现在印度还不能跟中国平起平坐。但由于我们有人口和资源优势,我们总有一天会赶超中国。


 


Sulav Karki


Originally Answered: Who is more powerful between India and China?


It’s a relative question. Both India and China are huge Countries with more than a billion people, Both have large armies although China has more and is more advanced and Both have nuclear weapons. India and China have actually fought already back in 1962 in which India lost but if a full fledged invasion were to happen, i don’t think there would be any clear winners and all losers. Economically, of course China is more powerful than India, in terms of military as well China is more powerful.


最初的问题是:中印之间谁更强大?


这是一个相对的问题。印度和中国都是拥有10亿多人口的大国,都拥有庞大的军队,尽管中国拥有更多、更先进的武器,而且都拥有核武器。印度和中国实际上早在1962年就已经打过仗了,当时印度输了,但如果全面入侵发生,我不认为会有明显的赢家和输家。在经济上,中国当然比印度更强大,在军事上,中国也更强大。


 


Yoginder Sharma, former War veteran- lost leg in 71; later GOC in C. at Indian Army (1955-1994)


Sure, for an Indian, India must always seem stronger and better.


But, seriously, how does one compare 'relative-strengths’ of the two most populous countries in the world? Is it a straight-line mathematical count of Military strengths. In that respect, China wins!


But, in the nuclear context, that is a simplistic way! Beyond the minimum-deterrence and assured second-strike capability, nuclear build-up is an overkill. Both are thus evenly balanced, by that bottom-line nuclear criteria!


At the geo-strategic level China has made a huge headway in the fields of Infrastructural development, cyber warfare, strategic-reserves and power-projection, and in its Complete National Power!


In all these, it is already in the super-power league, while we are still a developing regional power. However, a Sino-Indian conflict cannot remain contained, it will escalate into a global conflict, hence the importance of creating countervailing alliances.


译文来源:三泰虎 http://www.santaihu.com/47431.html  译者:Joyceliu


当然,对于一个印度人来说,印度必须永远看起来更强大、更好。


但是,严肃地说,如何比较世界上人口最多的两个国家的“相对优势”?这是对军事力量的线性数学计算吗?如果是那样的话,中国赢了!


但是,在核环境中,这是一种简单的方式!除了最低限度的威慑和确保的二次打击能力之外,建立核设施是一种滥杀滥伤。因此,根据核标准的底线,两者都是不相上下的!


从地缘战略高度看,中国在基础设施建设、网络战、战略储备、力量建设等领域取得了巨大进展,国家实力不断增强。


在所有这些方面,中国已经是超级大国,而我们仍然是一个发展中地区大国。然而,中印冲突无法得到控制,它将升级为全球冲突,因此建立制衡联盟非常重要。


 


Anonymous


Yes, I give a example.


是的,我举个例子。


9d9e0d8fgy1g28wlhevn5j20gq0cktgc.jpg

 


9d9e0d8fgy1g28wlh0nuuj20gq0mbgxk.jpg

 


This is where I just walked by. You see there are no skyscrapers, shitty place indeed. Even police patrol is needed to ensure no one will protest against the government. Sad!


Mumbai is indeed far better.


这就是我刚走过的地方。你看,这里没有摩天大楼,没有世外桃园。甚至需要警察巡逻,以确保没有人抗议。


孟买确实要好得多。


9d9e0d8fgy1g28wlgnylpj20gq0aawqi.jpg

 


 


Avkrishna Rao, studied at Master of Business Administration in Business Management


No!


Leave alone defence and economy!


In China people are assets and Indians are liability!


All these factors throw away all the positive elements into the gutter!


This is my opinion based on observation and no criticism please!


并没有!


更别提国防和经济了!


在中国,人是资产,印度人是债务!


所有这些因素把所有积极的元素都扔进了臭水沟!


这是我的观察意见,请手下留情!


 


Shaik Abdulhameed, works at Nellore, Andhra Pradesh, India


Originally Answered: China or India, who is stronger?


no doubt,china very stronger than india on both sides like econamy and military.but first we have to understand,when such country add nuclear weapons and medium range missliles it is not right to compare country's military strength. in case of economy chainas' imports huge than us,fully convertable market economy is our india's strength.we have to watch this china a permanent member of us security council but democracy is our main strength.black money and corruptions are main weaknesses of our country.


最初的问题是:中国和印度,谁更强大?


毫无疑问,中国在经济和军事方面都比印度强大。但首先我们必须明白,当这样的国家加上核武器和中程导弹,是不该和他比较军事实力的。在经济方面,中国的进口总值超过我们,完全可转换的市场经济是我们印度的优势。我们必须看到这一点,中国是联合国安理会常任理事国,但皿煮是我们的主要力量。黑钱和腐败是我国的主要弱点。


 


Abhinash Dutta


I have been reading the answers to the question and have seen that all the Chinese writers have answered in affirmative. I just can't help thinking that perhaps after posting their answers, they all are having a quiet laugh at our expense as we puff up with ego and pride. Alternatively the Chinese just may be too modest to show off their achievements.


我一直在关注这个问题的答案,我看到所有的中国用户都给出了肯定的回答。我只是忍不住想,也许他们在发布了答案后,都在默默地嘲笑我们,而我们却在骄傲、自负地自我膨胀。另外,中国人可能过于谦虚,不愿炫耀自己的成就。


 


Daniel Cohort, Big Data Director in China


No.


Chinese economy is way more stronger and diversified than India’s . India does not have what is required for a global power : manufacturing prowess.


As for military power, India has better relations with western countries, so it could obtain more western technologies than China does. But it seems India has not been able to make good use of it and its own defence industry is far behind China’s.


不可能。


中国经济比印度更加强大和多样化。印度不具备成为全球强国所需的条件:强大的制造业实力。


在军事力量方面,印度与西方国家的关系更好,因此印度可以比中国获得更多的西方技术。但印度似乎还没有充分利用这一优势,国防工业也远远落后于中国。


 


Robbie Jena, Industrial Ecosystems and Strategy Architect


Originally Answered: Who is stronger, India or China?


Long ago, like 100,000 years ago India and China were friends and equal to everything…Now in 30 to 60 years, same will happen.


最初的问题是:谁更强大,印度还是中国?


10万年前,印度和中国是朋友,平等相待,从现在起30到60年后,同样的事情还会发生。


 


Piyush Abhishek Singh


Originally Answered: China or India, who is stronger?


Well China is ahead in almost all aspect supported by statistics but in recent years China has made more enemy than friends while India has made more friends than enemy. In Layman terms India know how to live in a global society while China is behaving like a child. If China and India are placed politically on global level then India is ahead of china.


最初的问题是:中国和印度,谁更强大?


统计数据显示,中国几乎在所有方面都领先,但近年来,中国树敌太多,朋友太少,而印度的朋友比敌人多。通俗地说,印度知道如何在全球社会中生存,而中国却表现得像个孩子。如果中国和印度在政治上处于全球水平,那么印度领先于中国。


 


Tamim Taj, learner


Originally Answered: Who is more powerful between India and China?


I'm sorry my Indian friends to break this to you. But facts remain facts. In terms of military, china is ahead of India, economy ? China is ahead with all the obvious reasons, population ? They have more than India so more labor market. They've got land to cover all that people too.


Biggest reason why they're more successfull is because they're not divided like India


最初的问题是:中印之间谁更强大?


我很抱歉我的印度朋友,我必须得这么说。但事实就是事实。就军事而言,中国领先于印度。经济方面呢?中国领先的原因很明显。人口方面?他们有比印度更多的劳动力市场。他们也有土地养活所有的人。


他们更成功的最大原因是他们不像印度那么分裂。


 


Ramesh Raja, Managing Director at Real Estate (2004-present)


Originally Answered: Is China more powerful than India?


China’s economy is larger than India. China’s population is larger than India. China has military budget larger than India. China have more soldiers than India. So China is powerful than India.


最初的问题是:中国比印度更强大吗?


中国的经济规模比印度大。中国的人口比印度多。中国的军事预算比印度多。中国的士兵比印度多。所以中国比印度更为强大。


 


Raven Xu, B.S. Software Engineering, Northeastern University (2020)


Originally Answered: China or India, who is stronger?


only one point to explain it, China now is often compared with USA, but how about India? Who will compare India with USA


最初的问题是:中国和印度,谁更强大?


只需一点就能解释,现在中国经常被拿来和美国比较,但是印度呢?谁会把印度和美国拿来做比较呢?


 


Priyadarshan Gajendra, KNOWS English, Hindi, Telugu, Kannada and Tamil at Home (2007-present)


No one is stronger and no one is weaker. If you and me just plan to fight then, you will defiantly have 10 people behind you and even behind me same. The question is who is human to all the things in this Universe. Only Weapons manufacturers and suppliers and War dreamers will benefit and make profits, by making India and China fight to see them destroying themselves to make the lands not to live


这两个国家没有哪个更强,也没有哪个更弱。如果你和我打算开战,那么你背后肯定有10个人,我身后可能也有10个人。只有武器制造商、供应商和战争梦想家才会从中受益并获利,他们会让印度和中国斗个你死我活,看着他们毁灭自己,让土地不再适于居住。


 


Raul, Lead at Germany (2009-present)


No.. India knows it very well and hence it's politicians are too cautious while dealing with China. More than Chinese mighty army,India is worried about Chinese aggressive strategy- they have cheque book power, when they decide to take a decision, they don't Step back. That's their might,no country can dare to raise their eyebrows.. that's China. And for a surprise,Indian army stand has surprised everyone in world.


没有. .印度非常了解这一点,因此政客们在与中国打交道时会十分谨慎。比起中国强大的军队,印度更担心中国咄咄逼人的战略——他们手中有着支票簿,当他们决定做出决定时,他们不会退缩。那是他们的力量,没有一个国家敢挑衅他们。这就是中国。令人惊讶的是,印度军队的立场让世界上所有人都感到惊讶。


 


Iftikhar Alam, works at Startup Founders and Entrepreneurs


Originally Answered: Is china is more powerful than india?


最初的问题是:中国比印度更强大吗?


9d9e0d8fgy1g28wlg8r7pj20fw07ggmp.jpg

 


Is the gap widening or closing in? Widening?


You have your answer there..


China literacy rate: 96%


India: 72%


China GDP per Capita ranking: 72nd


India: 139th


China Population living under $3.1/day: 2.5%


India: 58.1%


这个差距是在扩大还是在缩小?扩大?


你们自己看吧。


中国识字率:96%


印度:72%


中国人均GDP排名:72位


印度:139位


每日生活费低于3.1美元的中国人口:2.5%


印度:58.1%


 


Sanjana Poddar, studied at MBGHSS


Originally Answered: China or India, who is stronger?


Right now china


In future india provided ppl start focusing on real issue rather thn the issue like gay marriage transformation of religion and other not so important stuff


最初的问题是:中国和印度,谁更强大?


目前肯定是中国。


未来,如果印度开始关注真正的问题,而不是像同性恋婚姻、宗教改革和其他不那么重要的问题时,印度也许会比中国更强大。


 


Srinivas Rao Holi, former Retired from private company.


Originally Answered: Is India stronger than China now?


In all aspects India is behind china


Like area, population,GDP, Economic activities, defences, Military,innovations,export market,domestic consuption,natural resources etc.


Now it is second biggest economy in the world after USA ,very soon it accelerate to first position.


最初的问题是:印度现在比中国强大吗?


印度在各方面都落后于中国。


比如国土面积、人口、GDP、经济活动、国防、军事、创新、出口市场、国内消费、自然资源等。


现在中国是世界上仅次于美国的第二大经济体,很快就能跃升至第一的位置。


 


Rowan Ma


no, it IS not. India has advantages such as average age, number of population, English skills…etc


but the disadvantages are also huge, level of education, social classes, poverty …etc. India will only be a stronger India, not the next China.


不,不是。印度有很多优势,比如平均年龄、人口数量、英语水平等等。


但缺点也很多,教育水平、社会阶层、贫困等。印度只会成为一个更强大的印度,而不是中国第二。


 


Kraj Sevim


No. Although both strong/powerful nations are skilled in the military, China might have some advantages. Manpower, and nuclear weapons.


不。虽然两个强国都擅长军事,但中国可能有一些优势。人力和核武器。


 


Harini Madhusudan, studied at Cluny Convent High School


Originally Answered: China or India, who is stronger?


I feel India has embraced it's huge population as an advantage. We have a huge population of youngsters. China on the other hand is technically advanced. Right now, China is the better country. But India does have the scope to advance.


最初的问题是:中国和印度,谁更强大?


我觉得印度已经将其庞大的人口作为了优势。我们有大量的年轻人。另一方面,中国的技术更为先进。现在,中国是一个更发达的国家。但印度确实有提高的空间。


 


Rajvansh Singh, lives in India


China is definitely stronger from india..


Be it army , nuclear weapons, political conditions and as research that it would be one of the leading countries of the world in the coming years…


中国肯定比印度更强大…


无论是军队、核武器、政治环境,还是研究表明,中国将在未来几年成为世界领先国家之一……


 


Crayon Elephant, International Field Agent at SFA (2018-)


I wonder who came up with this kind of meaningless questions? You dont even have to ask cuz the answer is too obvious - INDIA is stronger!


我想知道是谁提出了这种毫无意义的问题?你连问都不用问的,因为答案太明显了——印度更强大!


 


Kilian Zhang, A Humble Thinker


Yes. India is slightly stronger than China.


India has dem-cracy. China is a semi-authoritarian country. India wins. 1:0


India has population of 1.3 billion, China has 1.4 billion, but China’s aging. 2:1


India treats Pakistan as big threat. China little bit worry about Taiwan. 3:2


India has more West support, while most West countries see China as their biggest opponent. 4:3


Indian people are very creative at Religions. China imported Buddhism from India. So 30% of Chinese ideology actually shaped by Indian philosopher. 5:4


Indian people are better mastering English. While most Chinese can only speak Mandarin or even merely some kind of Chinese dialect no one can understand. 6:4


India managed to send their probe into Mars, while China still aimed Moon. 7:4


China has better infrastructure, such as high speed trains, highways, mega hydro-power plants. Although India is catching up. 7:5


India land mass 3+ million km² , China has 9+ million km², but most of area are desert, mountains. 7:6


India locates close to Persian Gulf, give them edge to get oil more easily and economically.


China’s oil shipping boat should pass Malacca Strait. 8:6


Nowadays China have 4 times bigger GDP(11.3 trillion $) then India(2.3 trillion $). But India has more higher GDP growth rate. 8:7


Overall, so far in December 2016, India is slightly stronger than China.


是的。印度略强于中国。


印度有皿煮。印度1:0。


印度有13亿人口,中国有14亿人口,但中国正在步入老龄化社会。印度2:1。


印度视巴基斯坦为巨大的威胁。中国则忌惮台湾,印度3:2。


印度得到了更多西方国家的支持,而大多数西方国家将中国视为最大的对手。印度4:3。


印度人在宗教方面很有创造力。中国从印度引入了佛教。30%的中国意识形态实际上是由印度哲学家塑造的。印度5:4。


印度人的英语水平更高。而大多数中国人只会说普通话,甚至某种没人能听懂的中国方言。印度6:4。


印度成功地将探测器送上火星,而中国还在研究月球。印度7:4。


中国有更好的基础设施,如高速列车、高速公路、大型水电站。不过印度正在迎头赶上。印度7:5。


印度国土面积为300多万平方公里,中国为900多万平方公里,但大部分地区都是沙漠和山脉。印度7:6。


印度靠近波斯湾,这让他们能更容易、更经济地获得石油。


中国的油船必须途径马六甲海峡。印度8:6。


如今,中国的GDP(11.3万亿美元)是印度(2.3万亿美元)的4倍。但印度的GDP增长率更高。印度8:7。


总的来说,截至2016年12月,印度略强于中国。


 


Pei Wang, Trainee at SFA


Definitely YES.


I don't see many aspects in which China is better than India. On the contrary, India perfectly exceeds China in many aspects.


For example,India has launched a rocket with astonishing 104 satellites! That's a remarkable achievement. But as I know China hasn't sent more than 10 satellites in one time.


Let's look at the economy, India’s economic growth rate now has surpassed China, and China is still on the down trend, this situation will last for many years. According to the report of Havard, by 2024, the economy growth rate of India will be more than 8%, while that of China is only 4.4%, so India can do much better than China. India has a large group of young laber forces, it’s population structure is very reasonable, but China is getting old, it lacks laber forces. So you can see India is on the rise in all aspects, but China is gradually going down. There’s no doubt that the future belongs to India, the whole world will see India growing stronger and finally becoming the world’s leader.


Now obviously we must say, India is stronger than China.


肯定是的。


我并未看到中国在很多方面优于印度。相反,印度在许多方面完全超过中国。


例如,印度发射了一枚载有104颗卫星的火箭!这是一个了不起的成就。但据我所知,中国单次发射的卫星数没有超过10颗。


让我们来看看经济,印度的经济增长率现在已经超过了中国,而中国仍然处于下降的通道,这种情况将会持续很多年。根据哈佛大学的报告,到2024年,印度经济增长率将超过8%,而中国只有4.4%,所以印度可以比中国做得更好。印度有大量的年轻劳动力,人口结构非常合理,但是中国正在步入老龄化社会,缺乏劳动力。所以你可以看到印度在各个方面都在上升,但是中国在逐渐下降。毫无疑问,未来属于印度,整个世界将看到印度变得越来越强大,最终成为世界的领导者。


所以,很显然,我们必须说,印度比中国更强大。


相仿文章
印度比中国强大吗,印网友:我们IT、医疗
印度GDP增速降至5.8%,低于中国,印
印度GDP增长率创6年新低,印网友:还是
2018年中国GDP增长6.6%,美国网
中国GDP第二季度同比增长6.2%
中国季度GDP降6.8% 首次负增长
中美签协议中金乐观中国GDP增速可调高至
世界银行预测,印度GDP在2019-20
印度人均收入增长将达两位数,印网友称人均
前首席经济顾问坚称:印度GDP增长率被高
印度前首席经济顾问:印度GDP实际增速比
印度第三季度GDP增长率降至6.6%,五
中国人均GDP未来20年内能赶超韩国吗
中国经济马上要超过美国了,为何印度人总喜
为何印度离5万亿GDP目标越来越远
人行专家: 建议大陆今年不设GDP增长目
IMF首席经济学家表示:印度需要修正GD
4小龙GDP遭病毒轰炸…谢金河断言台湾结
中国和印度在历史上曾经是朋友吗,印网友:
相同栏目
中国最大的万吨级大型海事巡逻船在广州出坞
1971年录音带曝光美国前总统尼克松的反
成龙公司回应成龙豪宅被拍卖:正处于诉讼阶
印度单日新增破4万例,印网民:真正开始爆
白宫"沦陷"特朗普急了:
美称疫情源于中国实验室 传德当局私下质疑
长征五号发射倒计时,长征五号又将迎来新的
研究人员在武汉医院的空气中发现病毒
总理确诊后,俄罗斯又一部长、副部长感染
4小龙GDP遭病毒轰炸…谢金河断言台湾结
世界最强军舰! 搭载导弹500多枚号称可
美国一机构称印度抗癌设备是“突破性”的,
这次不延期了,德里三座立交桥或提前9个月
美媒:双11成交额再破记录,中国经济实力
印度真的是一个很糟糕的国家吗
不速之客:一只老鼠是如何造成印度航空的航
印度人民党遭遇挫折,最富裕的邦脱离其控制
库雷希:印度已经偏离了甘地的道路
印度真的是一个伟大的国家吗
移民欺诈:8名印度人在美国被拘,其中6人

浙ICP备15039925号-2    部分网站可能在中国大陆地区无法访问,请谅解!
隐私提醒:本站使用了Cookie,帮助用户提供更好的服务。